Secrets on Teaching English in Japan-- EFL/ESL
The vast majority of people who come to Japan teach English. Most stay for a year or
two, then move on. Now at this point it's necessary to inject a little reality into the stories
going around out there. From the late '80s a lot of books and anecdotes have come out about
how YOU can earn BIG MONEY in JAPAN!! THREE jobs for every applicant!! No experience
necessary!!! The schools are practically camped out at your arrival gate RIGHT NOW just
waiting to SIGN YOU UP!!!! There are pieces of gold in the street just lying there for you
to take them!!! And every time the stories are recycled they get even more exaggerated. Well,
I hate to yank those glowing dollar signs out of your saucer-shaped eyes, but the reality isn't
quite so wonderful. Things were NEVER that rosy, not even in the "Bubble Days" of the
late '80s/early '90s; and tens of thousands of other westerners have read those books too and
they're already here in Japan. In fact, there is such a glut of labor that nearly every school
simply pays minimum wage, which is 250,000 yen per month. (Income taxes will eat up about
10% of that before you get it). That is enough to be relatively comfortable in smaller cities,
but in the big cities that is not living it up. And many schools these days can be choosy
enough to demand that applicants have special qualifications in EFL/ESL, or several years of
teaching experience, or both. This is not to say you can't get a job, or you must have an IQ like Einstein. The
truth is, teaching English at a conversation school is more entertaining than educating.
And if you are a young, single woman, you have an automatic advantage. In fact, going to the
job interview in a tight suit and high heels might just double your chances. Why? Because
the Japanese MEN who run the school would rather have a
western woman around, the vast majority of teachers are men, and the students (mostly
women, who self-segregate themselves through high school) would feel more open with a
woman than a man. In any case, a positive attitude, an outgoing personality, and having a lot of
interesting stories to tell are all important factors. Likewise, being in Japan is a big boost--it shows you're committed and ready to start
immediately. Personal contact is very important in Japan. Some big chain schools recruit abroad or allow
you to apply through e-mail, and it is still possible to land a job by mailing out a mountain of
resumes, but by and large for better jobs the people in Japan taking the face-to-face interviews will have
an edge. Most of the larger chain schools that hire outside Japan do so because they have soiled
reputations among teachers in Japan. Once the word is out, they are the workplaces of last choice and
taken for a quick visa while looking for a new school. On the other hand, getting an apartment in
Japan is often a tough grueling experience. Some long-term expats say that 4 out of 5 places
just refuse foreigners period. Being accepted at a big chain school can help out a lot, since they
provide accommodations. But if you quit or change jobs, you will of course be instantly evicted.
The Nova chain in particular draws a lot of fire since they bed you in with 1 or 2 other teachers,
but all the teachers pay full rent for the place.
Nearly all schools run on a one-year
contract system. Afterwards if you renew your visa, you can get up to a 3 year visa.
Note however if you lose your job or quit, you are required to
notify the government within 14 days.
Finding a job depends really on many factors -- experience, connections, your personal
appeal, and simple luck. Timing is also important -- many westerners think they'll just fly
on over in mid-summer, just before the beginning of the school year. Perfect right?
WRONG! The Japanese school year starts in April and hiring season is usually
January through March. If you miss this critical window, getting a job will be that much
harder. There are always some schools posting want-ads in the Monday edition of
The Japan Times throughout the year, but since
nearly every school runs on one-year renewable contracts starting in April, this begs the
question as to why they're looking for a teacher. Either they scored in getting a new influx
of students, or they hired and fired an incompetent teacher, a teacher decided to call it
quits, or they treat their teachers
like used toilet paper and they're looking for a new sucker. In the last case you'll find a
job all right but you'll also be getting much more than you bargained for. Working for a
big chain school may or may not be better than a small school -- it all depends on the
management. Teacher treatment can vary from being treated like a valued asset to a
necessary evil. So by all means try and find out how often the teacher turnover is. It's
simple -- better schools keep their teachers longer. If you find a place where very few or no
teachers stay on a second year, it's almost certain you've found a school you should stay
far away from.
Here is a quote (author unknown) from a net forum a few years ago, but still holds true
today. It offers a humorous look at the promise and reality of the eikaiwa experience:
For the vocationless graduate with a penchant for travel, the call of TEFL is strong. For the
penniless member of the same breed, unable to afford an RSA certificate, beware! A
teaching job in Japan is yours for the taking, if you’re prepared to, well...SELL YOUR SOUL.
Perhaps some will feel this is going to far. It is certainly true that there are some plum jobs
amongst the cherry blossoms. And yet, without having an insider’s view of the Japanese job
scene, it is very likely that you will end up mesmerized by the rampant, glossy, advertising of
the giants - Nova, Geos, Berlitz and the American-focused Aeon. These companies are the
corporate face of the English teaching market in Japan and prey upon those of us who
casually flip through the Guardian Education supplement of a Tuesday. Jostling for our
attention in the classifieds are numerous small ads promising great opportunities in Turkey
and Russia. Forget them. Allow your eyes to drift towards the reassuringly oversized and
sophisticated box that promises: “An Amazing Cultural Experience” and “International
promotion and career opportunities” and best of all “TEFL experience is an asset, but not
essential”. Wooo hooo! Lets go! And so many do.
In such a way I was lulled into sending an application form to one of the ‘big four’. A couple
of months later I found myself staggering towards a big sign in Narita International Airport -
‘Have a nice time in Japan, but don’t break the rules’ it both welcomed and cautioned. The
barely registered twinge of uneasiness I felt on reading this slogan was a sensation I was to
become familiar with in the following weeks and months. No, actually I take that back. The
twinge of uneasiness at the airport was like an orgasmic shudder when I compare it to what
awaited me at my new job. If I say I was misled by the London recruiters about my new life
and work in Japan, I don’t think I’ve quite covered the magnitude of the situation. The
following parable gets closer to how it was:
A recruiter of a big English-teaching company is hit by a bus and dies. She is met at the
gates of heaven by St. Peter who says, owing to an administrative hitch, they are unsure
where to place her - heaven or hell. Instead she is to be given the choice herself by
spending a day in each and then deciding.
Arriving in hell for her ‘taster-day’ she is met by the friendly faces of colleagues from her
company, dressed exquisitely in designer casuals. They greet her warmly and show her
around hell, which is a beautifully landscaped country club with golf courses and tennis
courts. She has a fantastic day playing sports, dining on lobster and steaks, dancing and
getting drunk with her friends. Everyone laughs at her jokes and she even gets to meet the
devil himself, who is, dare she say it, ‘kinda cute’. It is with great sadness that she leaves in
the evening.
The following day she spends in heaven. Here she hops from cloud to cloud, plays harps
and generally hangs out with the angels. Again she enjoys herself very much.
St. Peter asks her for a decision the next day. After great deliberation, she chooses hell over
heaven. ‘To hell you will spend eternity’, St. Peter decrees.
When she arrives the country club and golf courses are gone. In their place is a filthy,
desolate wasteland. Her friends are still there, but they are dressed in rags, picking up
garbage and putting it in sacks. The Devil comes up and puts his arm around her. "I don't
understand," she stammers, "yesterday I was here and there was a golf course and a
country club and we ate lobster and we danced and had a great time.
Now it’s a wasteland of garbage and all my friends look miserable.” The Devil looked at her
and smiled evilly. "Yesterday we were recruiting you; today you're staff."
It wasn’t all barren landscapes and torture. After all, I honoured my first year’s contract, and I
know many more who stayed longer (mostly, but not all freaks).
Admittedly there were others who only lasted a couple of days. With over 340 schools to fill
with some 4000 recruits from overseas, NOVA is the biggest single employer of foreign staff
and Geos is hot on it’s footsteps. Take it from me, their insatiable thirst for fresh faces is
less to do with growth, more to do with a high drop-out rate as new teachers discover, to
their dismay, the true meaning of the Japanese work ethic.
Though I would never outwardly encourage a person to apply for this kind of job, I wouldn’t
dissuade them either. I’d just warn them a bit, that’s all. It’s like those guys who perform acts
of self-mutilation on stage - you know, sticking swords down their throats and grinding their
faces in broken glass. Their claim is that, as they expect and prepare for the pain, they don’t
perceive it as unpleasant. This is the name of the game if you want to work for Nova et al.
Prepare yourself for the worst and you might just be able to keep a Zen head above water.
The beginning is the worst. Three days of training is all I apparently needed to become a
professional teacher; less really, as all teaching practice during this paltry training period
was performed on live, full-fee-paying clients. The fourth day was the first full working day.
‘Daunted’ would cover how I felt, as a previously qualified and experienced teacher of
English to the foreigner. Needless to say, I can’t speak for the majority of new teachers -
utterly inexperienced or qualified to teach anything at all. That first day, and every
consequential day thereafter, consisted of eight 40 or 45 minute lessons. Between each
class was a ten-minute interval. During this blink-of-an-eye pause, it was our duty to
evaluate each of the previous student’s performances, give them a mark, hunt for the files of
the next class, choose a new lesson, plan it, give a few whimpers of dismay, and go teach
again. This factory line approach to lessons - the antithesis of good teaching, as I knew it -
is the key to big bucks. The high quantity of classes taught at the school, along with a
blanket teaching style, is apparently the winning formula to attract the Japanese public. Fast
food English, you might say.
For anyone with ideals about being an original and conscientious teacher, this kind of job is
not for you. The strict lesson structure you are trained to use is not to be tampered with.
Superiors at my school would often keep an ear open on neighbouring classrooms to
ensure the right words were being said; the right lesson stages happening at the prescribed
times etc.
On the other hand, for those who need a job and are happy to put aside innovation and
imagination for the duration of their contract, you could be on to a winner. As far as I know,
all you need is a regular heartbeat and a university degree - a requirement of the Japanese
immigration authorities rather than your employer.
On a more positive note, you are helped with accommodation and basic set-up difficulties.
Hell, I was even given a company futon. There is ample opportunity to make and save
money as long as one doesn’t become too much of an alcoholic (it is worth noting that you
will become a bit of one, however hard you try). I lived comfortably for the first time in my
adult life and was able, on leaving Japan, to travel for a year. Extra incentive for men is that
you will almost certainly experience a renaissance in your love life. The foreign male is
viewed as quite a hot commodity amongst many Japanese women.
I must add that all of the above are possible with many of the smaller schools too. A little web
research is necessary to find out about them - their pleas for new teachers are rarely seen
in the British broadsheets. With a job at an unenfranchised school, you will have more
opportunity to experiment with materials and teaching methods. It is possible you will be the
only teacher, in which case, your chances of cultural and social interaction with your
students are much greater. The contract I signed stated that any interaction with students
outside the school would result in suspension or dismissal. Many an evening I would be
twiddling my thumbs or getting drunk with my English speaking colleagues, whilst my
housemate, employed at a tiny independent school, would be flooded with endless
invitations from her adoring students.
Working in Japan can be an “amazing cultural experience” and all the rest of it. It can also
be a pain in the arse. Ultimately it is up to us penniless graduates to do the necessary
enquiries and not succumb too quickly to the over-polished promises of the English teaching
giants.
It is very important to try and find out what place is somewhere you'd like to be.
Talking to other teachers (especially outside their workplace) who're
at the school you're looking at can give a lot of insight. Is the boss a
petty Napoleon? How much can you modify a lesson to meet the student's needs?
How much notice do you have to give to end the contract early?
What happens if you get sick? Do you get the minimum legally required 10 days
a year off? Will you ever get a raise or bonus? How much time do you have to
prepare for clases? Will the school pay your commuting costs? Will they pay some
or all of your health insurance? And will you be working on national holidays and
weekend nights? The contract is another good sign.
Many schools require 20-25 class hours per week, but these days some larger
school chains require a grueling 30 hours or more. Some schools try to virtually run their
teacher's lives, requiring them to be there 40 hours a week, even when they aren't
teaching classes. Will you be called on to do endless contractual "as other
duties require", like spending hours trying to wheedle students to sign up
and pay for another year? Some might also try to prohibit you from getting part-time work or private tutoring
(which is really how you make ends meet in Tokyo or Osaka). Some schools might
welcome your ideas on teaching and materials, others may just shove their own
curriculum down your throat. Given a choice, it would be better to hold out for a better
school. If you come all the way over to Japan to work, why not have a positive experience
instead of a nightmare?? The Japan FAQ:Know Before You Go (C)1998-2003 All Rights Reserved.
To read the lowdown on that company you just signed with, try
looking at the
Job Informational Journal.
You can also visit the whole version of The Japan FAQ:Know Before You Go by
clicking Or you can go on to these other pages in The Japan FAQ Annex
HERE